I think Pane E Vino deserves a full five stars! The food itself might deserve a four, but with the atmosphere, the extremely helpful staff, and the whole experience, I don't think it could get much better.
I went on a nice night and got seated on the outdoor patio. It's vine covered and adorable, with heat lamps that actually keep you very warm. I felt like I was back in Europe. The staff didn't rush us and let us take our time and stay for over 2 hours despite it being a busy night. They helped us pick a bottle of Italian wine that was a great choice.
I got the burrata to start, which was delicious! It was filled with chopped tomatoes with sliced garlic and everything tasted very fresh. I then got the Bucatini, which was spaghetti with pancetta and hot peppers in a tomato sauce. It was simple, but SO good. The pasta tasted homemade, which really decides if a dish like that is anything special.
The whole night was a great time, and I can't believe that it's as inexpensive as it is! Pasta dishes are mostly under $20, which is a great value for the quality and setting. I definitely recommend it, mostly for a night where you can enjoy the patio since the inside is small and would probably be less special.